While the day trading orule may have been intended to protect traders, it has become a significant barrier for smaller retail investors, exposing them to greater risks rather than providing true protection.
1. Lower the Minimum Balance Requirement
The $25,000 minimum balance is prohibitive for many retail investors, effectively excluding them from the benefits of day trading and creating an uneven playing field. By lowering the minimum balance to a more accessible level, (not more than $5,000), FINRA could enable more traders to manage their investments actively and responsibly without exposing themselves to overnight risks. A more accessible threshold would still promote responsible trading while allowing broader participation in the stock market.
2. Eliminate the 3-Day Rolling Limit
The restriction on only three day trades within a five-day rolling period unnecessarily limits flexibility and forces small investors into holding positions, which can be riskier due to market volatility. By removing the three-day trade limit and allowing unlimited day trades for traders who meet the adjusted minimum balance, FINRA could help retail investors better manage their risk on a daily basis without having to meet an excessively high financial barrier.
3. Consistency Across Financial Markets
Notably, the United States is the only country with such restrictions on day trading in the stock market, and similar limits do not exist for other high-risk markets, such as cryptocurrency, forex, or even casinos. This inconsistency in regulations suggests that the PDT rule unfairly limits U.S. retail stock traders while leaving them more exposed to market risks. Allowing fair access to day trading would bring the stock market in line with other financial sectors and promote a level playing field.
Adjusting these aspects of the PDT rule would make day trading more accessible and fair while still promoting responsible trading practices. Thank you for considering these proposed changes to modernize the PDT rule for today’s trading environment.
For the Public
FINRA DATA
FINRA Data provides non-commercial use of data, specifically the ability to save data views and create and manage a Bond Watchlist.
For Industry Professionals
FINPRO
Registered representatives can fulfill Continuing Education requirements, view their industry CRD record and perform other compliance tasks.
For Member Firms
FINRA GATEWAY
Firm compliance professionals can access filings and requests, run reports and submit support tickets.
For Case Participants
DR PORTAL
Arbitration and mediation case participants and FINRA neutrals can view case information and submit documents through this Dispute Resolution Portal.
Need Help? | Check System Status
Log In to other FINRA systems
Ahmed Comment On Regulatory Notice 24-13
While the day trading orule may have been intended to protect traders, it has become a significant barrier for smaller retail investors, exposing them to greater risks rather than providing true protection.
1. Lower the Minimum Balance Requirement
The $25,000 minimum balance is prohibitive for many retail investors, effectively excluding them from the benefits of day trading and creating an uneven playing field. By lowering the minimum balance to a more accessible level, (not more than $5,000), FINRA could enable more traders to manage their investments actively and responsibly without exposing themselves to overnight risks. A more accessible threshold would still promote responsible trading while allowing broader participation in the stock market.
2. Eliminate the 3-Day Rolling Limit
The restriction on only three day trades within a five-day rolling period unnecessarily limits flexibility and forces small investors into holding positions, which can be riskier due to market volatility. By removing the three-day trade limit and allowing unlimited day trades for traders who meet the adjusted minimum balance, FINRA could help retail investors better manage their risk on a daily basis without having to meet an excessively high financial barrier.
3. Consistency Across Financial Markets
Notably, the United States is the only country with such restrictions on day trading in the stock market, and similar limits do not exist for other high-risk markets, such as cryptocurrency, forex, or even casinos. This inconsistency in regulations suggests that the PDT rule unfairly limits U.S. retail stock traders while leaving them more exposed to market risks. Allowing fair access to day trading would bring the stock market in line with other financial sectors and promote a level playing field.
Adjusting these aspects of the PDT rule would make day trading more accessible and fair while still promoting responsible trading practices. Thank you for considering these proposed changes to modernize the PDT rule for today’s trading environment.