Stephen DeVience Comment On Regulatory Notice 22-08
Stephen DeVience
N/A
I oppose restrictions on the public's ability to invest in complex products for numerous reasons.
1. The definition of a complex investment is vague, arbitrary, and subject to administrative change in the future. This can cause a new risk for investors who may hold these products now but may be restricted from them in the future, forcing them to sell the products.
2. Being a complex product does not necessarily reflect the riskiness of the product compared with other investments. A complex product following a single commodities future such as oil is likely less risky than the stock of a pharmaceutical startup.
3. Complex products allow retail investors to diversify their portfolio, hedge investments during times of volatility, and seek enhanced returns without riskier strategies such as using margin.
4. Restrictions such as wealth tests only serve to benefit the wealthy, who will be able to use complex products to their advantage while others can't. Wealth tests also do not reflect whether the user of the product is actually an intelligent investor. Wealthy people can be poor investors and many people with less money can be intelligent investors.
5. Product information is disclosed to all investors and it is the responsibility of the investor to learn and understand what those mean. If FINRA finds that retail investors are investing in products they don't understand, it may be reasonable to have the investors make some kind of acknowledgement before they are allowed to invest in them, so that they know these types of products exist and which types are considered complex. It is then their responsibility to learn about how they work.
6. People also invest in stocks with risks they don't understand. If these complex products can be restricted because they are considered risky, one could make the same argument for many classes of companies.
For the Public
FINRA DATA
FINRA Data provides non-commercial use of data, specifically the ability to save data views and create and manage a Bond Watchlist.
For Industry Professionals
FINPRO
Registered representatives can fulfill Continuing Education requirements, view their industry CRD record and perform other compliance tasks.
For Member Firms
FINRA GATEWAY
Firm compliance professionals can access filings and requests, run reports and submit support tickets.
For Case Participants
DR PORTAL
Arbitration and mediation case participants and FINRA neutrals can view case information and submit documents through this Dispute Resolution Portal.
Need Help? | Check System Status
Log In to other FINRA systems
Stephen DeVience Comment On Regulatory Notice 22-08
I oppose restrictions on the public's ability to invest in complex products for numerous reasons.
1. The definition of a complex investment is vague, arbitrary, and subject to administrative change in the future. This can cause a new risk for investors who may hold these products now but may be restricted from them in the future, forcing them to sell the products.
2. Being a complex product does not necessarily reflect the riskiness of the product compared with other investments. A complex product following a single commodities future such as oil is likely less risky than the stock of a pharmaceutical startup.
3. Complex products allow retail investors to diversify their portfolio, hedge investments during times of volatility, and seek enhanced returns without riskier strategies such as using margin.
4. Restrictions such as wealth tests only serve to benefit the wealthy, who will be able to use complex products to their advantage while others can't. Wealth tests also do not reflect whether the user of the product is actually an intelligent investor. Wealthy people can be poor investors and many people with less money can be intelligent investors.
5. Product information is disclosed to all investors and it is the responsibility of the investor to learn and understand what those mean. If FINRA finds that retail investors are investing in products they don't understand, it may be reasonable to have the investors make some kind of acknowledgement before they are allowed to invest in them, so that they know these types of products exist and which types are considered complex. It is then their responsibility to learn about how they work.
6. People also invest in stocks with risks they don't understand. If these complex products can be restricted because they are considered risky, one could make the same argument for many classes of companies.